Skip to main content

Something to consider closely

Reading a novel, which we all know is fiction, but then I think about the old adage often used in the classroom - all fiction is based on fact.  The following quote comes from The Round House by Louise Erdrich that has caused me to stop and think.  Maybe someone out there will see the same thing I do.
Take Johnson v. McIntosh.  It's 1823. The United States is forty-seven years old and the entire country is based on grabbing Indian land as quickly as possible in as many ways as can be humanly devised. Land speculation is the stock market of the times. Everybody’s in on it. George Washington. Thomas Jefferson. As well as Chief Justice John Marshall, who wrote the decision for this case and made his family’s fortune. The land madness is unmanageable by the nascent government. Speculators are acquiring rights on treaty-held Indian land and on land still owned and occupied by Indians—white people are literally betting on smallpox. Considering how much outright grease is used to bring this unsavory case to court, a case pled by no less than Daniel Webster, the decision was startling. It wasn’t the decision itself that still stinks, though, it was the obiter dicta, the extra incidental wording of the opinion. Justice Marshall went out of his way to strip away all Indian title to all lands viewed—i.e., “discovered”—by Europeans. He basically upheld the medieval doctrine of discover for a government that was supposedly based on the rights and freedoms of the individual. Marshall vested absolute title to the land in the government and gave Indians nothing more than the right of occupancy, a right that could be taken away at any time. Even to this day, his words are used to continue the dispossession of our lands. But what particularly galls the intelligent person now is that the language he used survives in the law, that we were savages living off the forest, and to leave our land to us was to leave it useless wilderness, that our character and religion is of so inferior a stamp that the superior genius of Europe must certainly claim ascendancy and on and on (Erdrich 228).
 Does this make anyone else out there wonder about the rights of first peoples denigrated by Eurocentric laws created to steal and desecrate what is sacred even today?  

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ALL PIPELINES 10/20 - STOP GENOCIDE & it’s not in Gaza/Ecosystem Attack/StandWithUkraine/climate/Human Rights/ProtectSacred Sites

Love the byline. This is one of many things that stand out in this op-ed: “The latest collision between [Felon47’s] misrepresentation and reality came in a unanimous 7th Circuit per curium opinion upholding the U.S. District Court’s opinion finding that there was no legal basis for National Guard deployment in Chicago.” Yup, that convicted felon is losing again: " Put differently: Government lies to the country will not fly in court.” Too bad they don’t call the felon out on ALL his lies as well as those of his uh regime. This is a good read that we need to see whenever this corrupt regime attacks its citizens. Too bad the SCOTUS is just as corrupt as this regime. Strong opening sentence in the conclusion.  - The 7th Circuit rejects lies about Chicago The possibilities of what you can do over these next 15 days is given right underneath a picture from this weekend. Really don’t care if that incompetent, unhinged, misogynistic thang loses his temper. He isn’t worth squat IMO. Anywa...
Post a Comment
Read more

ALL PIPELINES 10/13 - STOP GENOCIDE & it’s not in Gaza/Ecosystem Attack/StandWithUkraine/climate/Human Rights/ProtectSacred Sites

Of course the village idiot is blaming the Dems for this shutdown when in fact it’s him and his chicken party is what is responsible, always has been. IMO he’s trying to divert attention from this with what is happening in the Middle East. If this corrupt regime is not placing back pay now on the GOP in Congress, he’s looking to switch responsibility to them. Guess what, fool. It doesn’t work that way. We KNOW who’s responsible who is really incapable of governing. Remember this always. Post it somewhere so you remember who is responsible for this stuff we’re all going through with the shutdown: “They’ve worked so hard to have us forget about the Epstein files and what they contain [I haven’t so I doubt it’s working elsewhere]. Let’s make sure they don’t do that.” Btw, WE are the focus of what the Dems want to pass. Many of us, especially those in Jersey are hoping the arguments heard today will disqualify U.S. Attorney Alina Habba. This is a good read. - The Week Ahead  Interestin...
Post a Comment
Read more

ALL PIPELINES 9/24-25 - STOP GENOCIDE & it’s not in Gaza/Ecosystem Attack/StandWithUkraine/climate/Human Rights/ProtectSacred Sites

You know who has little smarts at all, if any. I doubt it. This is yet another example. Oh, and he wants to see his name in the media, well here it is. What a doofus. He’s such a loser. He can’t do anything right. Mona Charen is Greg Sargent’s guest today. This is the content: " We discuss just how corrupt the anti-Kimmel effort truly is, how far [Felon47]is getting in suppressing dissent, and why there are grounds for optimism that the culture and civil society are now fighting back. ”   I don’t know about you but I know I will continue fighting back against this incompetent. I love seeing MAGAs and that big orange bully of a convicted felon losing. Keep it happening. IMO even doing what that fool does openly, it is NOT okay. We’re not ignorant like MAGAs and their fearless “leader”. Screw their whataboutism.  3 guesses what they can do with those. Vance is a blatant fool. What a tool! Screw what they call reality. Laughing at TACO.  - Trump Just Accidentally Wrecked MAG...
Post a Comment
Read more